Sunday, May 06, 2012
What's In an Award? Thoughts on the Pulitzer Snub
This year, no Pulitzer Prize was awarded for fiction. Three novels were nominated. Some say this snub is as it should be, that nothing good enough is out there right now. Some say this is a reflection of the Pulitzer Committee's elitist attitude. Some think it's a result of the increasingly commercial emphasis in the publishing world at the expense of true literary quality. Some say the committee just nominated the wrong stuff.
I couldn't help balking at this snub. With all the writing out there in this digital explosion of the written word, was there really nothing worthy of the recognition of the Pulitzer Prize? At a time when bookstores are going under and the possible death of the printed book haunts the horizon, is this the statement the committee wants to make? My first reaction was "What a slap in the face to every writer working today!"
But it turns out this isn't the first time the committee refused to award a prize. And there have been some pretty great books published during the years that no prize was awarded. In fact, we humans have a long tradition of failing to recognize great work that is ultimately vindicated by posterity. Tolkien's LORD OF THE RINGS was passed up for the Nobel Prize because of supposedly "second rate storytelling." CITIZEN KANE didn't win a best picture Oscar. The lesson here is that external validation has its limitations, and what readers and posterity ultimately recognize as valuable may never receive the establishment's stamp of approval.
So, write your story. Then go ahead and throw your hat in the ring for whatever external validations are out there, but know they never tell the whole story.
I've spent the past few days working on a character wheel for the protagonist of a young adult novel I'm writing called SCHISM, wh...
A depression-era circus, the Florida everglades, a dystopic future society, Nazi Germany - all settings of great books I've read in ...
This week, I've been thinking about seeds and writing . I've been thinking about what some people call writer's block and othe...
So here I was preparing to write a post about the Catch-22 of the introverted writer profile and the current demand that writers excel a...